Would You Feed Your Dog A $40 Steak?

Foie Gras

Despite the fact that so many people love going out to fancy dinners at fine dining restaurants that can cost you over $30 or $40 a head (or a whole lot more), I genuinely wonder if this is an effective use of their money. Let me explain: I am extremely skeptical of the abilities of the average person’s palate. Can you taste the difference between a $40 steak from Ruth’s Chris and, say, a $20 steak from Outback Steakhouse? If you like steak I’m sure your immediate thought is “of course I can!” So my next question is: can you tell me what makes one steak cost $20 more than another, only in terms of flavor and maybe appearance?

Let me also say I completely understand that a trip to any of these very expensive restaurants is considered more than just a meal – it’s an experience. There is no way I can valuate the “experience” of these restaurants, and I know this. My point here is to get you to ask yourself if it’s worth it to splurge so viciously on expensive dinners if you really just want great food.

I bring this up because the good folks over at Freakonomics have pointed out a new book by Robin Goldstein in which he poses taste tests to see if people can discern a great wine from an average one. (read: expensive vs. cheap) In fact, Steven D. Levitt actually conducted his own taste test on the hoity-toity poseurs known as the Harvard Society of Fellows. Guess what happened. Of course, one is not exactly a large sample size, so here is another example of a taste test by Dan Ariely, this time for those beer lovers out there.

Not one to discriminate against food, let’s take foie gras as an example. It is painfully expensive, but oh-so delicious. It’s pretty much the best form of meat pate/mousse. But while I, and many, many other people think its flavor is mouth-wateringly delectable, I doubt I can even distinguish everything that’s great about a good piece of foie. Knowing good from bad is one thing, but to actually have a flavor palate that can discern flavors is rare, I would argue. Maybe so would some economists at The American Association of Wine Economists who decided to play the same game as the aforementioned wine and beer folks, and then they decided to prove it. It might not be delicious, but odds are you have no idea what dog food tastes like.

So next time you treat yourself and your wife/girlfriend/hot date to a fancypants dinner, just remember that most of the value you get out of it is as much from the experience as it is from the food.

– RT

4 Responses to Would You Feed Your Dog A $40 Steak?

  1. Vince says:

    How can a sample size of 18 with 5 different categories have results which are statistically significant?

  2. RT says:

    I’m not entirely sure how serious these people are taking themselves, but at least they titled it a “Working Paper,” which might mean they’re continuing their study with more experiments? Don’t get me wrong, 18 is a hilariously small sample size, and they even admit their own methods may have influenced the results. But I’m going to hope that this was really just one of those small experiments to see whether the topic is worth serious exploration (read: grant money) or not.

    Also, the story just amuses me in general. =)

  3. antiny says:

    well said. i’m not too picky with food as long as i enjoy the environment i’m in. yet, i guess ppl pay for that “quality” and “authenticity” they think they’re buying whether they’re getting it or not.

    p.s. that picture reminds of what a chef said to me once “the first bite is with the eyes”

  4. RT says:

    And that first bite looks delicious right? Yeah, that’s what I was going for. ;) But I agree, the environment makes a huge difference in how I judge and end up remembering the food I eat. And I find it harder to enjoy expensive meals at snooty restaurants just because my standard are infinitely higher, despite the fact that I probably can’t tell the difference between pretty good and great. Extreme excellence, though, is always noticeable.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: